17. October 2021

High court challenge to Victoria’s electric vehicle tax


Two electric vehicle drivers have launched a High Court authorized challenge in opposition to the State of Victoria, arguing it lacks the constitutional energy to tax drivers with a street consumer cost.

The plaintiffs, Kathleen Davies and Chris Vanderstock, are represented by Equity Generation, the identical authorized agency that acted for eight youngsters in a landmark local weather court motion in opposition to federal Environment Minister Sussan Ley.

Engineering consultant Kathleen Davies is one of the plaintiffs taking the Victorian government to court over the electric vehicle tax.

Engineering guide Kathleen Davies is likely one of the plaintiffs taking the Victorian authorities to court over the electric vehicle tax. Credit:Jason South

In July, Victorian Treasurer Tim Pallas launched a controversial new levy which costs electric vehicle drivers between 2 and a couple of.5 cents for each kilometre they drive.

Equity Generation lawyer Jack McLean mentioned the structure divides powers between the states and the Commonwealth, and offers the Commonwealth the unique energy to levy taxes of this sort.

His two shoppers will allege that the Victorian levy is a tax on the consumption of electric autos, and the facility to levy that tax solely rests with the Commonwealth.

“It’s also simply bad public policy, it’s bad for the climate, and it’s standing in the way of our state embracing the future and moving towards a more sustainable transport sector,” Mr McLean mentioned.

Victorian Treasurer Tim Pallas introduced the levy.

Victorian Treasurer Tim Pallas launched the levy. Credit:Paul Jeffers

“It is a really strong disincentive to people looking to make the switch to a cleaner, more sustainable car.” he mentioned.

Transport is Victoria’s second-biggest contributor to greenhouse gasoline emissions, after its ageing coal-fired energy vegetation, and these emissions are nonetheless rising. Cars are answerable for half of those transport emissions.


Plaintiff Kathleen Davies, an engineering guide who lives in Melbourne’s east, purchased her first electric vehicle, a Nissan Leaf, in 2012.

Her household appreciated having an electric automotive a lot that in 2017 they upgraded to a BMW i3, with a “range extender” – a small petrol-driven motor that will increase the gap the vehicle can journey between costs.

When Ms Davies first heard in regards to the Victorian authorities’s proposal to tax electric autos she thought it was a joke.

“It’s grossly unfair. I have spent 15 years trying to reduce my reliance on fossil fuels and this stops the easy adoption of electric vehicles,” Ms Davies mentioned. “People will view them as more expensive to run.”

Ms Davies has by no means taken authorized motion earlier than, and considers it an avenue of final resort. But she took the step after 15 years of private local weather motion, becoming a member of native motion teams and lobbying politicians.

She was impressed by the partially-successful class motion introduced by Equity Generation on behalf of eight youngsters in opposition to Ms Ley. This challenged a proposal by Whitehaven Coal to prolong its Vickery coal mine in NSW, arguing it might endanger their future.

The court dismissed the youngsters’ software in May to stop the minister approving the coal mine extension, and Ms Ley accredited it on Thursday. But the court did discover Ms Ley owed an obligation of care to Australia’s younger individuals. Ms Ley is appealing this decision.

When she learn in regards to the court case Ms Davies contacted Equity Generation and agreed to be concerned on this electric vehicle court case.

“Those kids are so brave, and I’m just a middle-aged woman trying to understand how we shift the system.”

Those youngsters are so courageous, and I’m only a middle-aged girl attempting to perceive how we shift the system.

Kathleen Davies

Fellow plaintiff and Melbourne nurse supervisor Chris Vanderstock, who makes use of his automotive for his day by day work commute, mentioned he had further considerations to the constitutional validity of the legal guidelines.

“Instead of taxing clean technologies, the Victorian government should be concentrating on getting dirty cars off the road,” Mr Vanderstock mentioned.

The latest Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change report discovered international emissions should peak throughout the subsequent 4 years to preserve warming at 1.5 levels.

And though Victoria has joined different international jurisdictions by setting a goal of reaching internet zero emissions by 2050, that is unlikely to occur if the state’s transport emissions proceed to enhance.

The state Labor authorities says the tax will make street charging fairer for all motorists as a result of electric vehicle drivers don’t pay gas excise. Mr Pallas has mentioned the cost would set up the required tax infrastructure as electric vehicle uptake grows towards an anticipated 26 per cent of all cars in Australia by 2030.

He additionally mentioned the $30 million anticipated to be raised by the brand new cost, over 4 years, will likely be greater than offset by $45 million spending to increase the take-up of electric autos, with charging factors throughout the state and plug-in amenities in new buildings.

Mr Pallas mentioned Victoria was investing in the way forward for electric autos and making certain everybody pays their fair proportion for constructing and sustaining roads.

“This reform will deliver broad benefits to the public in the long-term, including less congestion, reduced road maintenance expenditure, less urban sprawl and further transport mode shift,” he mentioned.

Infrastructure Victoria, the state’s key infrastructure adviser, just lately mentioned Victoria ought to cease the sale of latest petrol and diesel autos by 2035 to cut back greenhouse gasoline emissions and encourage extra individuals to purchase zero-emissions automobiles.

Widespread electric automotive use wouldn’t solely assist the state to attain its internet zero goal by 2050, but additionally save thousands and thousands of {dollars} annually in well being and environmental advantages, it mentioned in its report, Victoria’s infrastructure technique 2021-2051, tabled in parliament.

The authorities has been contacted for remark.

The Morning Edition e-newsletter is our information to the day’s most essential and fascinating tales, evaluation and insights. Sign up here.

Most Viewed in Environment


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About us

SANJHI AWAAZ is Punjabi radio station based in Melbourne (Australia) catering for all age groups of the Punjabi and Hindi speaking communities in the Melbourne VIC (AUS) and across the world online.